How to Handle Cold Email Replies and Objections

Five kinds of reply
  1. 1Yes: book a time
  2. 2Not now: set a date
  3. 3Have a tool: ask the gap
  4. 4Too costly: ask value
  5. 5No: thank and stop
The short answer: sort every reply into yes, not now, already have something, too expensive or no. Answer yes within hours, set a reminder for not now, ask what the other tool does not do, ask what value would justify the price, and always thank a no and stop.

If they say yes

Offer two times and send the invite the same day.

If they say not now

Ask when to check back, write it down and do it. This is often a future yes.

If they use something else

Do not argue. Ask what it does not do. If it works, thank them. If they name a gap, that gap is your next email.

If they say too expensive

Ask what outcome would make it worth it. Do not discount at once.

If they say no

Thank them, remove them from the list and honour any opt out immediately.

A worked example

A buyer writes: "We already use another tool." The founder replies: "Thanks for letting me know. What does it not do well for you?" The buyer says reports take too long. The founder answers with one sentence on how the product handles that and offers a ten minute look. That gap became the next email in the sequence for similar companies.

Common mistakes

  • Arguing with an objection instead of asking about it.
  • Replying to a no with a longer pitch.
  • Dropping a "not now" without a reminder to check back.
  • Offering a discount before you know the objection.

Where Touchbase fits

Touchbase finds companies that fit what you sell, says why each one fits, writes a plain first email for each that you approve before anything is sent, and handles replies and follow-ups. You choose who to write to and what goes out.

Find your first customers with Touchbase

Touchbase finds companies that fit what you sell, writes each first email for you to approve, and handles the follow-ups. It is free to start, with no card.

Start free

Questions

Should I reply to a no?
A short thank you is polite. Then stop.
What if they ask for more information?
Send a short note and one link, then offer a call.
How fast should I reply?
Within a few hours if you can.

Stop waiting for customers to find you

Tell Touchbase what you sell. It finds the companies that need it and the person to write to at each, and drafts a first email for you to read and send.